Nutter Butter Cookie Bars Melts – ScentSationals ReviewNutter Butter Cookie Bars

by Christina Rylan

Brand: ScentSationals

Scent: Nutter Butter Cookie Bars

Type: 2.5oz Clamshell Melts

Price: $2.00

These melts were purchased at Walmart


First impression of Nutter Butter Cookie Bars:

Have you smelled Nutter Butter Cookie Bars yet? My bakery loving eyes zeroed in on this one the moment I spied it on a Walmart shelf. Nutter Butter Cookie Bars… um… YUM!!! When I smelled the wax, I smelled a peanut butter bakery scent. Very warm and doughy. Loved it right off the bat. The picture on the label shows peanut butter bars with a layer of chocolate. I didn’t really smell chocolate in this scent but if I do once melting, I won’t mind. That sounds yummy.

Really crossing fingers this scent is a room filler.



The only scent description for this scent was, “sweet childhood memories.” Doesn’t really explain the scent but you kind of already know what it is – Peanut Butter Bars and it truly does smell like it.

I used the entire clamshell pack (3 cubes each) in two electric melters in my great room. Once melting, it took a good 15 minutes before the aroma was traveling through my great room and at first it smelled super light but that didn’t last long. 30 minutes in, the scent was everywhere and itPeanut Butter Cookies smelled really yummy. My entire great room smelled like peanut butter cookies. Soft and chewy peanut butter cookies.

Strength – I would rate these melts an 8 out of 10 in a super large room. 10 in medium to smaller rooms.

In closing, if you love warm peanut butter bakery scents, you’re going to love Nutter Butter Cookie Bars. It smelled pretty realistic.

Happy melting!

~ Christina

Visit ScentSationals

Presentation: 5/5
Authenticity: 5/5
Strength: 4/5

Overall rating: 5/5

Read more ScentSationals reviews


  1. Brad H. February 16, 2018
    • christina February 16, 2018

Leave a Reply