Spotted Hog Philly Butter Cake vs. Birthday Cake? What's the difference

[rikku9 0]

Does anyone have both the Spotted Hog "Philly Butter Cake" and "Birthday Cake" scents? I was wondering how different they are from each other. I have the "Birthday Cake" and love it but was wondering if I should get the "Philly Butter Cake" and how it compares.

[sweet&spiceygrl 1]

rikku9! Wish I could help ya, but I've only tried their Philly Butter Cake so can't compare, but I really like that scent & think it's deeelish!

[biolaeagles 0]

I'm with Sweet...I haven't tried the Birthday Cake, but the Philly Butter Cake is TO DIE FOR.

[ChristinaR 0]

I've tried both and love both. PBC is more buttery and richer. Birthday cake is a classic fluffy cake to me. You can't go wrong with either.